Aquino v. Kuczinski, Vila & Associates, P.C. 39 A.D.3d 216, 835 N.Y.S.2d 16 (A.D.1st Dpt. 2007)
Student Contributor: Maninder (Meena) Saini
NY Underlying personal injury action
Facts: On July 4, 2002, plaintiff-client slipped and fell in the lobby of a casino that caused back injuries. On July 9, 2002, plaintiff retained an attorney to represent her in this matter. The attorney wrote letters to the casino on two separate occasions, advising them of the plaintiff’s claim and requesting insurance information and surveillance footage. The casino failed to send the requested information. In July 2004, the plaintiff contacted the attorney where he told her no action was commenced and the two-year statute of limitations had expired. Plaintiff then brought a lawyer malpractice action against the attorney and law firm alleging the failure to investigate plaintiff’s case and to timely commence an action.
Issue: Did the plaintiff show that “but for” the negligence of the attorney she would have prevailed in the litigation?
Ruling:: The Appellate Court held that plaintiff failed to show she would have succeeded on the merits of the case “but for” the attorney’s negligence. Specifically, the court stated that “[d]efendants’ negligence in failing to investigate plaintiff’s case and timely commencing an action does not relieve plaintiff of her burden of proving that she would have prevailed in that litigation but for defendants’ negligence”.
In order for a plaintiff to succeed on a lawyer malpractice claim, a plaintiff must plead and prove a prima facie case of legal malpractice. The proximate cause element of he cause of action requires that she demonstrate that she would have succeeded on the merits of the underlying claim “but for” the attorney’s negligence.
Lesson: Even though the attorney was negligent in failing to investigate the plaintiff’s case and timely commence an action, the plaintiff failed to prevail because she could not demonstrate a "but for" causation utilizing the "trial within a trial" method of proof.
Tagged with: But for-Proximate Cause
Posted in: But for-Proximate Cause